Bill McKibben on the Pandemic, VTDigger, and Vermont’s Deplorables

Here’s a recent comment by Middlebury College’s enviro activist in residence Bill McKibben, which makes an interesting point.

“The pandemic has also been hard on [Vermont’s] newspapers, which have been curtailing editions and laying off staff. But Vermont is also lucky to have two more-or-less statewide independent media outlets: the entirely Web-based VTDigger and the Burlington-based alternative weekly Seven Days.”

“Both have done something unusual and useful during the pandemic: they have shut down their comments sections. They did it to make sure that people weren’t spreading bad information about public health, but the secondary effect has been to isolate the small number of soreheads and malcontents who monopolize such venues.” That reminds you of Hillary Clinton’s characterization of her detractors as “Deplorables”, doesn’t it?

In the case of VTDigger, which I readily admit performs a valuable service for the state, I did a quick analysis of the first ten comments posted on the report of  the July Senate passage of the Global Warming Solutions Act. Seven commenters were opposed to that bill, and three were supportive. I added up the positive and negative responses, and found that the opposition prevailed by a ratio of 1058 to 103 (91% opposed).

Two weeks later VT Digger discontinued comments on the dubious grounds that it took too much staff time to moderate them. In my view, it’s more plausible that they got tired of publicizing the views of McKibben’s soreheads and malcontents who opposed the Digger-favored climate agenda.

John McClaughry is vice president of the Ethan Allen Institute.


Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.

Enter Comment Here:

  • Ivan St George
    commented 2020-08-24 16:35:51 -0400
    If anyone believes the Vermont press in general is fair and balanced they need their heads examined.
    If not for Guy Page with Vt Chronicle and water cooler, EAI and True North reports, the Green Mountain
    Polit bureau pundits like Vt Digger, Seven days , channel 3,4 5, Pbs, and Dave Gram would rule the day
  • Vincent Hunter
    followed this page 2020-08-22 12:09:32 -0400
  • Tom Rood
    commented 2020-08-22 08:55:05 -0400
    Although I expected they were fed up with all the contrary responses to most of their articles from all the nay-saying soreheads, I contacted VTDigger for an explanation of the comment shutdown a week ago.

    Still waiting for a response.
  • Thomas Koch
    commented 2020-08-21 17:24:58 -0400
    Yep. The media likes to monopolize political thought. Allowing comments from us deplorables and malcontents challenges their agenda.
  • Chris Weinheimer
    followed this page 2020-08-21 17:10:06 -0400
  • David Flemming
    commented 2020-08-17 15:44:54 -0400